A History of the Confraternity of St. Benedict
Introduction
The Benedictine Guild is a Confraternity of St. Benedict. This essay asks what that word means, where it came from, and how it came to be joined to Benedict’s name. The story begins with Christians remembering their dead by name. It passes through monastic prayer unions, books of life and letters of fraternity. It reaches a lay confraternity in Benedict’s honor in the early 1200s, a Spanish grant in 1580, an English rule printed in 1639, and an American grant in 1865. It closes with a practice taken up again today.
The threads are real, but they are threads, not one rope. Where the records join, this essay says so. Where they do not, it says that too.
Part I. The word
Brother, fellow brother, brotherhood
The word is built from Latin parts. Frater means brother. The prefix con means with or together. A confrater is a fellow brother, and a confraternitas is a brotherhood of such fellows. [1]
The Medieval Latin word passed into Old French as confraternité in the fourteenth century and into English in the late 1400s. [2] English dictionaries still give two senses. One is a society devoted to a religious or charitable cause. The other is simply fraternal union. [3] Latin also had a shorter form, confratria, and the older word fraternitas was often used for the same thing. [4]
One dictionary keeps an older and more exact sense of confrater. It describes an associate of a monastery who received a share in its prayers without taking on its vows or its way of life. [5] That is very close to what this history is about.
Letters of fraternity
Before English had the word confraternity, it had the phrase “letter of fraternity.” Middle English writers used fraternity for a religious order or society, for membership in one, and for the letter a religious house gave to a brother or benefactor. Such a letter entitled the holder to a share in the prayers and good works of the house. In 1443 a man in York left money to a Carthusian house in his will “with my letter of fraternite.” [6] He wanted to be remembered by the monks, and he had the letter to prove his claim.
So the word arrives in English already carrying the idea at the heart of this history. A person living in the world is joined to a praying community, and that bond is written down.
Part II. Before the word: remembering by name
The names of the dead
From early times Christians prayed for one another by name, living and dead. In Merovingian Gaul names were read aloud at Mass on Sundays and feasts, and prayers were written to go with them. [7] To be named was to be remembered before God.
Benedict’s Rule
The Rule of St. Benedict, written in the sixth century, does not describe a confraternity. It does lay down the habits from which one would grow. Every guest is to be received as Christ (chapter 53). A wise elder keeps the gate and answers each knock with a blessing (chapter 66). Parents may offer a child to the monastery (chapter 59). The Rule opens its doors to the world even as it orders a life apart from it.
Later Benedictine tradition told stories of lay people asking to share in that life. One tells of Tertullus, father of St. Placid, asking Benedict to receive him into the brothers’ fellowship. [8] The story is late and cannot be used as history. It shows how naturally later Benedictines read their own custom back into Benedict’s day.
Part III. Monks praying for one another
The prayer union of Attigny, 762
One of the earliest documented prayer unions was made among bishops and abbots, not lay people. Around 762, at a Frankish synod at Attigny, Bishop Chrodegang of Metz and dozens of other bishops and abbots bound themselves together. When one of them died, each survivor would have the psalter said a hundred times and a hundred Masses offered for him, and say thirty Masses himself. [9] German historians call it the Totenbund, the league of the dead. A standard view holds that the custom of confraternitas came to the Franks from England. [10]
Books of life
Out of these unions came books of names. A confraternity book, in Latin liber confraternitatum or liber vitae, records the names of people who entered a spiritual brotherhood with a church or monastery. The monks or priests prayed for everyone named in it. [11]
One of the oldest is the confraternity book of St. Peter’s in Salzburg, begun in 784 when the abbey was also the seat of the bishop. [12] Others survive from St. Gall, Reichenau and Remiremont. [13] The Durham Liber Vitae was begun in ninth-century Northumbria. At Durham, monks added their own names and those of lay friends until the Reformation. A later account remembers the book resting on the high altar. [14]
The idea behind these books is simple. A name written there would be prayed for at the altar, day after day, long after the person had died.
Part IV. Lay friends of the monks
Kings and benefactors
By the eleventh century monasteries were writing lay people into their books and their prayers. Christ Church, Canterbury recorded confraternity with King Cnut, his brother and several Scandinavian laymen. [15] In 1263 or 1264 the monks of Canterbury granted confraternity to Louis IX of France, his queen and their children and promised them commemorative services. The sealed original survives in Paris. [16]
Hundreds of English letters of fraternity survive from the later Middle Ages. A study in the 1920s catalogued about 280. [17] They show that ordinary benefactors, not only kings, could ask to share in the prayers of a monastery.
The Italian custom
Italian Benedictines kept the same custom. The Cassinese Congregation’s declarations on the Rule, printed in 1520, provide for annual Masses for those who held their litterae gratiosae, their letters of grace, and for the monks’ parents and siblings to share in the congregation’s good works. [18] This matters later. The English writer Anthony Batt would say that the Spanish monks learned the custom from the Italians.
Part V. Lay confraternities
A letter from a monastery joined its holder to the prayers of the house. Lay confraternities made room for another kind of bond. People bound themselves to one another, often under a patron saint, with a rule of their own.
Carolingian laws of the eighth and ninth centuries already mention confraternities and guilds. [19] Surviving statutes show English fraternities around the year 1000 binding members to keep the peace. [20] In twelfth-century Italy, lay people and clergy gathered in confraternities to pray and care for their neighbors. [21] By the end of the Middle Ages confraternities were everywhere. Their purpose, as one historian puts it, was above all ethical. [22] Members made peace, cared for the sick, buried the dead and prayed for one another.
Part VI. A confraternity in Benedict’s name: Tulebras
In the early thirteenth century, neighbors in Navarre formed a confraternity in St. Benedict’s honor.
At the convent of Santa María de la Caridad in Tulebras, in Navarre, a Cistercian abbess and a company of lay people, clergy and nuns established “this fraternity in honor of St. Benedict.” Its statutes survive. Members met each month. They made peace when they quarreled, visited the sick and buried their dead. The parchment preserves a roster, and a later hand calls them “the brothers of St. Benedict” and the “confraria” of St. Benedict. [23]
The date on the charter is damaged. The early thirteenth century is as close as we need to come. The statutes do not mention a scapular, and no record connects this fellowship to the later English confraternity. What the parchment does show is that people were already gathering in Benedict’s name to pray and care for one another.
Part VII. Spain: the brothers and sisters of Valladolid
A custom of fellowship
The Benedictines of San Benito el Real in Valladolid led a reform congregation that spread across Spain. Their book of benefactors remembers a royal official, Fernán Díaz de Toledo, who died in 1457, as a brother and benefactor in his lifetime. Another entry records the reception of an archdeacon as a brother around 1500. [24] The custom of receiving friends into fellowship was well established.
The shorter scapular, 1430
In 1430 Pope Martin V allowed the congregation’s vowed service brothers to wear a scapular shorter than the monks’ and to share in the monastery’s spiritual goods. [25] These were not lay people living at home, and the grant does not describe the small devotional scapular of later centuries. It does show the scapular, a piece of the monastic habit, being shared in a lesser form.
The grant of 1580
On January 27, 1580, Pope Gregory XIII granted indulgences to the whole Valladolid congregation. The grant includes “those whom they call brothers and sisters,” admitted or to be admitted to share in the congregation’s prayers, suffrages and good works. [26] It offers an indulgence for a nightly examination of conscience and three Our Fathers and three Hail Marys for the Roman Pontiff and the Holy Roman Church. It grants a plenary indulgence for monthly confession and Communion with prayer, and another for invoking the name of Jesus three times at death, aloud or in the heart if unable to speak. When three Masses were said for a deceased member, the indulgence was for the departed soul.
The grant mentions neither a scapular nor a Creed. It did not found the fellowship. It names brothers and sisters whom the congregation was already receiving, and it gives us the clearest point of comparison with the later English rule.
Part VIII. England: the Confraternity of the Scapular
Exile and a legal bridge
The dissolution of the monasteries between 1536 and 1540 broke up the houses that had received lay friends into their prayer. A generation later, young English Catholics went abroad, and some became Benedictines in Spain and Italy. In 1619 Pope Paul V united the English monks into one congregation and extended privileges of the Spanish and old English congregations to it. The brief does not single out the Valladolid grant. [27]
The Mission Constitutions
The English monks worked as priests in England, where Catholic worship was outlawed. As Batt reproduces them, the Constitutions for the Mission set out how lay people were to be received. Chapter VIII, numbers 28 to 31, gave the rule. Only the President, the Provincials and Priors, or a few they deputed could admit anyone. Admission was not to be given easily, only to those found worthy by their virtues. The entrant was to go to confession and if possible to Communion. A priest blessed a small scapular, reminded the entrant of the duties, clothed them with the words “Receive the sweet yoke of Christ, and his burden which is light,” and received them by authority granted from the Holy See. The entrant’s name was written in the book of the confraternity. [28] A printing of these Constitutions was made at Douai in 1633. [29]
Batt’s treatise, 1639
In 1639 Anthony Batt, an English Benedictine at Douai, printed A Short Treatise touching the Confraternitie of the Scapular of St. Benedicts Order. It is the earliest printing of the full title identified here. Batt was preparing an English edition of the Rule and of Gregory’s Life of Benedict, and the elder fathers asked him to add the letters of fraternity and answer common objections. The President General, Clement Reyner, approved it at Douai on August 27, 1639. [30]
The treatise gives the letter of admission in full. Members were “to weare in secret a little scapular.” Each night they were to examine their conscience and so place themselves in the disposition “in which by Gods grace you would not feare to die.” Then they prayed the Our Father and the Hail Mary three times and the Creed once, “for the exaltation and happie successe of the Catholicque, Apostolicque, and Romane Church.” [31] None of it bound under sin. Members shared in all the Masses, prayers, fasts and good works of the order, in life and after death.
Batt reproduces the Mission Constitutions and then defends the practice. In his third chapter he says the English monks received the custom from the monks who first brought the faith to England. After their banishment, he says, they received it again from the Spanish congregation, which had learned it from the Italians. He points to Spain’s 97th privilege, the grant of 1580. [32]
The indulgence clauses closely parallel one another. One difference matters. In Valladolid the indulgence for three Masses goes to the departed soul. In Batt the Masses are still offered for the departed, but the promise is addressed to the member who arranges them. The English rule includes the little scapular and the Creed, neither of which appears in the Spanish grant. It casts the nightly examen as preparation for death and gives the prayers a different intention. The likeness makes sense of Batt’s citation. It does not tell us when or where the English features first entered the rule. [33]
Batt’s later chapters answer critics. To the charge that sharing merits was heresy, he answers that it works by asking God, as the Church does in all its prayers. To those who asked how this differed from the communion of saints, he offers an image. A citizen of a town also belongs to the kingdom. Members of the confraternity share in the communion of all the faithful and in a special communion besides. [34]
Part IX. To America
London, 1861
In 1861 a London Manual of Devotions to Our Holy Father S. Benedict printed the English rule, the letter and the rite again. The manual says admission still belonged to the President General and the superiors of the English congregation. It also reports papal rulings of 1838 and 1854 confirming the indulgences. [35]
Wimmer’s petition, 1865
Abbot Boniface Wimmer brought the Benedictines from Bavaria to Pennsylvania in 1846 and built a network of monasteries and parishes. He had come to depend on the prayers and support of lay friends. In 1865 he asked Rome to allow the confraternity in the churches under his congregation’s care, naming the English form as his model. Pope Pius IX granted it on August 6, 1865. [36]
The short name, 1868
Three years later the Benedictine ritual printed at Latrobe published Wimmer’s petition and Rome’s reply under the title Confraternitas S. P. N. Benedicti, the Confraternity of Our Holy Father St. Benedict. [37] It is the earliest printed example of this short title identified here. Franz Beringer records that in 1882 and 1883 Rome granted the monasteries of the Cassinese Congregation of the Primitive Observance permission to establish the confraternity in their churches as well. [38]
Some reference works later placed the confraternity’s origin in the nineteenth century. [39] Batt’s treatise shows it was more than two centuries older.
Part X. A change in practice
In 1967 Pope Paul VI reformed indulgences. The handbook issued in 1968 simplified the grants and reduced their number. [40] That change tells us less about this confraternity than we might wish. No central body carrying on the historical association has been identified in these records. The name is still in use elsewhere: the Anglican St. Gregory’s Abbey in Three Rivers, Michigan, keeps a confraternity of its own. [41]
The 1983 Code of Canon Law gave the faithful a clear right to form associations among themselves by private agreement, with statutes of their own. [42]
Part XI. Today
Something old, sought again
The reforms of the last century had good reasons. They meant to clear away a counting of days and years and to turn the faithful toward charity and the heart of the liturgy. There is still a loss worth naming. A little scapular, a prayer said each night, a name written in a book: these were small ways for people to stay close to the Church’s prayer. It is worth asking what they might offer us now.
In France the bishops’ figures put adult baptisms at Easter at 4,124 in 2016 and 10,384 in 2025. [43] Their 2026 survey counted more than 21,000 adults and adolescents preparing for Easter baptism. [44] Those figures don’t undo a long decline. They do remind us that people are still looking for a faith they can live, and that some will begin with a practice small enough to keep each night.
Taking up the rule again
The Benedictine Guild is one small answer for people still looking. It takes up the rule of 1639 for people today. It is a private association of the faithful. It keeps its rule and its spirit. Members examine their conscience each night, pray the Our Father and the Hail Mary three times and the Apostles’ Creed once for the Church, wear a scapular or a medal, and pray for one another, living and dead. Their names are written in a register, as the names of friends of the monks were written in the books of life.
Its history is a long line of people who asked not to be forgotten, and of communities that promised to remember them.
Notes
What the records show
The Tulebras statutes name a confraternity in Benedict’s honor in the early thirteenth century. The Valladolid grant of 1580 names brothers and sisters and describes the nightly prayers. Batt cites that grant in the English treatise of 1639, and Wimmer names the English model in his 1865 petition. None of these records traces a line from Tulebras to Valladolid or dates the first use of the small scapular in the English confraternity.
Sources
- Merriam-Webster, “confrater,” from Medieval Latin, from Latin com- and frater, brother. ↩
- Dictionary.com, “confraternity,” late Middle English confraternite, from Medieval Latin confrāternitās, 1425–75. Online Etymology Dictionary, “confraternity,” late fifteenth century, from Old French confraternité (fourteenth century). ↩
- Merriam-Webster, “confraternity.” ↩
- Catholic Encyclopedia, “Confraternity (Sodality)” (1908), giving Latin confraternitas and confratria. ↩
- Merriam-Webster, “confrater,” sense 2. ↩
- Middle English Dictionary, “fraternitē,” sense 1(c), citing a York will of 1443. ↩
- Els Rose, “Inscribed in the Book of Life: Liturgical Commemoration in Merovingian Gaul,” Oxford Handbook of the Merovingian World (2020). ↩
- A Manual of Devotions to Our Holy Father S. Benedict (London, 1861), p. 212, citing Surius from a Life of St. Placid. See note 35. ↩
- Encyclopedia.com, “Attigny, Councils of.” Catholic Encyclopedia, “Councils of Attigny” (1907). The date is given as 762 or 765. ↩
- Karl Schmid and Otto Gerhard Oexle, “Voraussetzungen und Wirkung des Gebetsbundes von Attigny,” Francia 2 (1974), quoting Theodor Schieffer. ↩
- Lynda Susan Rollason, The Liber Vitae of Durham (Durham University, 2003), pp. 191–193, on books of names and the prayers offered for those entered in them. ↩
- Salzburg, Erzabtei St. Peter, Archiv, MS A 1, digital facsimile, p. 14. Karl Forstner, ed., Das Verbrüderungsbuch von St. Peter in Salzburg (Graz, 1974). ↩
- Rollason, The Liber Vitae of Durham, pp. 191–193, on the surviving books of Salzburg, St. Gall, Remiremont and Reichenau. ↩
- Lynda Rollason, Durham Liber Vitae thesis. William Aird, “Death and Remembrance: the Durham Liber Vitae,” Cardiff Historical Papers. D. and L. Rollason, eds., The Durham Liber Vitae (British Library, 2007). ↩
- Canterbury, Christ Church confraternity records. “Brotherhood and Confraternity at Canterbury Cathedral Priory,” Archaeologia Cantiana 128. ↩
- Archives nationales, J461, no. 2215. Élie Berger, Layettes du Trésor des Chartes, IV, no. 4803. Nicholas Vincent, commentary to no. 81, p. 209, on the competing dates. ↩
- “Some Further Letters of Fraternity,” Archaeologia. ↩
- Regula with Cassinese declarations (Florence, 1520), final declaration, fol. 91r. ↩
- Catholic Encyclopedia, “Confraternity (Sodality).” ↩
- Gervase Rosser, “The Ethics of Confraternities,” manuscript p. 9, on early English confraternities and restraint of violence. ↩
- Neslihan Şenocak, “Twelfth-century Italian confraternities as institutions of pastoral care,” Journal of Medieval History 42, no. 2 (2016), pp. 202–225. ↩
- Gervase Rosser, “The Ethics of Confraternities,” chapter 2. ↩
- Archivo General de Navarra, Clero, Tulebras, no. 138. Alfonso Andrés, ed., statutes of the confraternity of St. Benedict at Tulebras, Zurita (1934), pp. 17–20. ↩
- Libro de los bienhechores of San Benito el Real, Valladolid, Fitzwilliam Museum, MS Charles Fairfax Murray 28. Published edition, fol. 20va (p. 229) and fol. 33rb (p. 244). ↩
- Privilegia praecipua Congregationi Sancti Benedicti Vallisoletani (Valladolid, 1595), privilege LII, fols. 108v–110v. Google Books scan. ↩
- Gregory XIII, Quo fidelium animarum saluti sedulo consulimus, January 27, 1580, ibid., privilege XCVII, fols. 197r–198v. ↩
- Paul V, Ex incumbenti, August 23, 1619, in Clement Reyner, Apostolatus Benedictinorum in Anglia (Douai, 1626), Appendix I, no. XXV, pp. 24–25. ↩
- Anthony Batt, A Short Treatise (Douai, 1639), chapter II, pp. 9–12, quoting the Constitutions for the Mission of England, ch. VIII, nos. 28–31. ↩
- Constitutiones Missionis Benedictinorum Congregationis Anglicanae (Douai: L. Kellam, 1633), Cathedral Libraries Catalogue, B767. ↩
- Batt, approbation. ↩
- Batt, chapter I, pp. 3–8. Full scan. ↩
- Batt, chapter III, pp. 13–14 and p. 21. ↩
- Compare note 26 with Batt, chapter I. In 1580 the indulgence for three Masses goes to the departed soul. In 1639 it goes to the living member who has the Masses offered. ↩
- Batt, chapters V and VII. ↩
- A Manual of Devotions to Our Holy Father S. Benedict (London: Dolman, 1861), pp. 211–218. ↩
- Rituale et caeremoniale Benedictinum (Latrobe, 1868), pp. 12–15, printing the petition and the reply of August 6, 1865. ↩
- Ibid. ↩
- Franz Beringer, Die Ablässe (1893), pp. 693–694. ↩
- Catholic Encyclopedia, “Scapular,” which gives conflicting thirteenth and nineteenth century accounts. ↩
- Paul VI, Indulgentiarum Doctrina (1967). Apostolic Penitentiary, Enchiridion Indulgentiarum, historical preface to the fourth edition (1999). ↩
- St. Gregory’s Abbey, “Confraternity and Oblates.” ↩
- Code of Canon Law, cc. 298–329, especially c. 299. ↩
- French Bishops’ Conference, 2025 retrospective and 2026 catechumenate report, historical series. ↩
- French Bishops’ Conference, 2026 catechumenate report, published before Easter. ↩